IDOL Week 4: MK's Top 9 Picks!

It was Elton John night and most ROSE to the occasion and a few fell FLAT. The following are my TOP 9!

1. James Durbin (Adam would be pleased): He literally set the stage on fire. This rocker’s in it to win it.

2. Scotty McCreery: This “What Me Worry” cowboy stays in the saddle… and the little girls (and Boys)understand.

3. Jacob Lusk (Have you heard the Gay Rumors?): Still in the top ranks, is he a little too overwrought for the general public?

4. Pia Toscano: She killed the ballad in an elegant, no-nonsense fashion, still the TOP Female.

5. Stefano Langone: He kept his eyes open and sang to J. Lo. He has Looks and Talent and is this year's Eye candy. Keep Him Going!  



6. Naima Adedapo: Didn’t help her chances with a risky reggae version… I LOVED it!

7. Paul McDonald: His low-key charm has brought him this far, but is he too understated to go the distance?
8. Casey Abrams: The judges’ favorite, but how long will his shtick go over now that he’s been humbled?

9. Haley Reinhart: (She DID it right for once) Her raspy vocals and shapely legs caught Tyler’s eye… Will it do the same for voters?

Which 2 will Go?

Lauren Alaina: Still America’s sweetheart…But Her song (Country version of Candle in the wind was Lame) 


Thia Megia: One ballad too many for this Filipino prodigy? Time to Go.