Rand Paul, Sharron Angle and other high profile Tea Party politicos often describe themselves as constitutional constructionists. That is, they favor a strict reading of our Founding Fathers' intentions, and our laws, state or otherwise, must reflect those ideals. Tyler Clementi and other cyber-bullying targets' suicides raises serious questions about the Tea Party's static perspective, according to Towleroad.
Dharum Ravi and Molly Wei, the two students accused of broadcasting Clementi's sexual encounter, thus sparking his suicide, are charged with invasion of privacy. As prosecutors work out the sordid and virtual details, however, the charges may be changed to include a possible bias, thus upping a potential sentence.
Regardless of how prosecutors proceed, the circumstances illustrate how common laws aren't always equipped for our evolving culture.
"What should the punishment be for acts like cyberbullying and online humiliation?" asked the New York Times' Joshua Schwartz over the weekend:
That question is as difficult to answer as how to integrate our values with all the things in our lives made of bits, balancing a right to privacy with the urge to text, tweet, stream and post.
And the outcry over proper punishment is also part of the continuing debate about how to handle personal responsibility and freedom. Just how culpable is an online bully in someone’s decision to end a life?
New Jersey and other states' laws have never dealt with something of this nature, and there will no doubt be challenges in the future, as the Internet and virtual antagonism reach new heights. This creates a problem for those who believe the Constitution, and by extension our nation's laws, should remain rooted in the past.
Our nation has grown tremendously since its revolutionary founding, and it will only continue to grow. Our laws and reading of the Constitution need to grow with it.
But there's no easy answer to how far our laws and reading of the Constitution need to expand, because where do you draw the line? The Supreme Court will help answer that question today, when it hears the free speech-related case against the Westboro Baptist Church.
Our nation, however, will consistently struggle with these questions, and that includes Tea Party candidates, who are going to have to explain how they balance a changing world and age old legal interpretations.
U.S. News - Breaking News and Latest Headlines
Celebrity News, Photos and Videos - HuffPost Celebrity
LGBT News, Culture, Opinion and Conversations
Monday, October 4, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Popular Posts
-
by Alan Bounville Below is my extended response to the article titled “T he LGBT Grassroots vs. HRC: Fighting for a One-Bill Equality St...
-
Wonder Woman Approved! Anderson Cooper, Jeffrey Tambor, Judith Light, Laverne Cox, Rupert Friend, Lynda Carter, Ross Mathews, Jussie Smo...
-
Associated Press reporter David Crary tweets that NOM's Maggie Gallagher has been replaced as the organization's chair by Chapman U...
-
Zachary Quinto , the former Heroes star who transitioned to the big screen as Mr. Spock in Star Trek, is currently appearing on the New York...
-
Host M.K. Scott interviews Entertainment Weekly's Dave 'Mr. Oscar' Karger on his predictions for the 2010 Academy Awards.
-
Larry Keith, who had supporting roles in Broadway shows ranging from the original production of My Fair Lady to Titanic and Caroline, or Ch...
-
Last fall, I had the pleasure of attending Birthday cake at SLGFF and was by far the Best. It is a sequel to a short film called Groom ...
-
Amber Genuske and Oliver Noble have compiled the above HIGHLY NSFW montage as a tribute to phalli on film. They are not always big, th...
-
Justin Robinette , the Chairman of the College Republicans at Duke University, was impeached last week for “conduct unbecoming of a person i...
-
BOMBSHELL: Brendon Ayanbadejo Cut By The Baltimore Ravens AND Says Up to four players to Come OUT at Once! PUNK'D: Gay Repor...
Contributors/Series
Our Favorite Sites
- Boy Culture
- Deep Dish
- Edge Seattle
- Fancast
- GLBT Yellow Pages
- Gay Crawler
- Gay Dating on OneGoodLove.com
- Greg in Hollywood
- Jesse Archer
- Kenneth in the 212
- Mark's List in Florida!
- Newser
- Out in Seatttle
- PQ Monthly
- Planet Homo
- Queer Me Up
- Seattle Gay News
- Smoking Cocktail
- The Stranger
- Towleroad
- Trans Lives Matter
- Views from a Broad
- We Love Soaps
- Wicked Gay Blog
Creative Commons License
OutView Online by MK Scott is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.
Based on a work at www.outviewonline.com.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available at http://www.outviewonline.com/p/contact-us.html.
No comments:
Post a Comment